Security March 15, 2024 12 min read

ISO 27001 Certification vs Accreditation

What You Need to Know Before Selecting an Auditor

Introduction

So you've made the decision: ISO 27001 certification is on your horizon, probably 2-3 years down the line. May be it's driven by customer demand, regulatory pressure or a genuine desire to strength your information security posture. As you refine internal processes and implement controls, you would also need to scout for an audit firm.

Once you begin the search, things often get confusing. There are countless firms, unfamiliar jargon and prices vary a lot for apparently the same certificate. Here’s how to bring clarity to the chaos:

Key Takeaway

Choosing the right audit firm is a crucial part of the ISO 27001 journey, yet the process is often unclear and full of jargon.

Understand the basics: Certification vs. Accreditation Bodies

It's crucial to understand the key players involved in the certification process:

Certification Bodies (CBs)

These are the firms that actually conduct your ISO27001 audit. They assess your Information Security Management System (ISMS) and issue the certificate if you meet the requirements. However, not every certification body is authorized to do so. Certification bodies must be accredited i.e. they must be formally recognized and regulated by an accreditation body.

Accreditation Bodies

These firms authorize and oversee certification bodies. They ensure that audits are conducted with integrity, consistency, and in accordance with global standards. These bodies are loosely overseen by a global association called International Accreditation Forum (IAF).

Each country usually has at least one recognized accreditation body, though some may have more than one. For example:

  • India: NABCB (National Accreditation Board for Certification Bodies)
  • United Kingdom: UKAS (United Kingdom Accreditation Service)
  • United States: ANAB (ANSI National Accreditation Board)

A list of accreditation bodies that are members of IAF is given on the official website of IAF.

Pro Tip

The logo of the “accreditation body” will be on the ISO27001 certificate as well as that of the CB but you will not have any contact with the accreditation body.

How to Select an Audit Firm (Certification body)?

Choosing the right certification body for ISO 27001 is a strategic decision—it affects your credibility, global recognition and even how smoothly your audit process goes. Here’s what to ask when choosing an ISO 27001 audit firm:

Are they accredited and approved for ISO 27001 audit ?

Select a firm that is accreditated by a valid accrediation body registered with IAF and ensure that it is currently approved for ISO 27001 audit. You also need to verify on the IAFcert website that they are accredited to certify ISO 27001. Some CBs may be accredited for other standards like ISO 9001, but not ISO 27001.

Do they have experience in your industry ?

Choose a firm that understands your domain. Industry specific auditors understand your operational context and can assess controls more effectively. They’re better equipped to spot real risks and offer insights that are both practical and meaningful.

Do they have a clearly defined audit process ?

Understand how the certification body conducts audits. Ask for a breakdown of how they conduct Stage 1 and Stage 2 audits, including timelines, documentation requirements and reporting formats. A transparent process helps you prepare confidently and ensures your team knows what to expect.

Do they have positive feedback from similar organizations?

Reach out to peers or industry groups to learn about their experience with the certification body. Ask about audit quality, professionalism, responsiveness and post-audit support. The feedback helps you avoid surprises and choose a partner that aligns with your expectations.

Do they offer clear guidance on surveillance audits ?

After certification, your organization will undergo periodic surveillance audits, typically once a year, to ensure continued compliance with ISO 27001. These audits are less intensive than the initial certification but still review key controls and risk management practices. Ask the certification body how they structure these audits, what documentation is required and how they handle findings or nonconformities.

Pro Tip

Most top-tier certification bodies offer a Stage 1 audit that acts like a dry run. Use it strategically to identify gaps in your ISMS before the formal Stage 2 audit. Engage your auditor in meaningful dialogue during Stage 1 audit. Ask how they interpret key clauses, what trends they’re seeing across industries and where they think your controls could evolve. The best insights often come from the questions you ask - not just the ones they do.

Conclusion

Choosing the right ISO 27001 certification body is a strategic move—it impacts your credibility, global recognition, and how smoothly your audit goes. If the audit firm is accredited, experienced in your industry, has a transparent audit process, comes highly recommended and offers clear guidance on surveillance audits, you’re well on your way to a smooth and credible certification experience.